Bank of Canada governor designate Tiff Macklem attends a news conference on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada May 1, 2020. (Blair Gable/Reuters)
News Analysis
OTTAWA—The Bank of Canada gave a modest surprise on Oct. 26 by raising its overnight rate target by only 50 basis points (half a percentage point)—instead of 75 basis points—to 3.75 percent. Such a move could indicate the end is in sight for one of the most aggressive rate-hiking cycles the BoC has ever undertaken, albeit for different reasons, according to analysts.
“My reading of their decision was that they wanted to err on the side of caution,” Vivek Dehejia, an economics and philosophy professor at Carleton University, told The Epoch Times.
It would appear most of the heavy lifting has been done after total rate increases of 1.75 percentage points in July and September, and a total of 3 percentage points since March prior to the October decision. But even after the October hike, the BoC says there’s more to come.
“This tightening phase will draw to a close. We are getting closer, but we are not there yet,” Bank of Canada governor Tiff Macklem said in the opening remarks of the bank’s press conference.
“We judged that it was appropriate to slow the pace of increases in our policy rates from very big steps to a big step,” Macklem said.
Economists are forecasting the rate hikes to stop once the BoC’s overnight rate target reaches 4 percent or 4.25 percent. The last time the bank’s policy rate was 4 percent was in March 2008.
End Is Near
TD called the rate increase a “dovish shock,” saying that it gives the impression that the Bank of Canada is about to pivot from being more aggressive on raising interest rates. But the bank has also come under more political pressure of late.
“It also raises thorny questions about central bank independence, given that prominent politically connected individuals were calling for the BoC to slow the pace of tightening earlier this week,” TD said in a note.
RBC’s interpretation is that the peak in interest rates is near.
The October rate hike marks the sixth consecutive time the BoC has raised rates this year.
“Today’s decision puts a bit more emphasis on the economy. Hopefully that doesn’t come back to haunt them in 2023 if inflation remains stickier than expected,” said Benjamin Reitzes, managing director and strategist at BMO, in a note.
The Bank of Canada noted that, as a result of past rate hikes, housing activity has “retreated sharply” and spending by households and businesses is softening.
Another outsized rate hike is particularly painful for those paying variable-rate mortgages. The commercial banks’ prime lending rate is 2.25 percent above the BoC’s overnight rate target, and with additional rate increases expected, the prime rate could be close to 6.5 percent when the rate hike cycle ends.
Canada and other major economies are amid a high interest rate, high inflation period with economic growth rapidly slowing—a stagflationary environment.
It’s “not a happy message” for Canadians facing these factors and potentially a recession, Dehejia said.
“Obviously, there’s a sense of compassion for people who are more in trouble, but if you don’t deal with the problem now, the problem just keeps getting worse and gets harder to solve. So that’d be my point.”
Regarding the chance of a recession—defined as two consecutive quarters of negative economic growth—toward the end of 2022 or the beginning of 2023, the BoC said that this is just as likely as having a small amount of positive growth during this period.
This is a result of downgraded economic growth projections in quarterly forecasts published in the central bank’s monetary policy report (MPR) released Oct. 26. Compared to July’s MPR, 2023 growth is revised notably lower—from 1.75 percent to just under 1 percent.
Beating the Inflation Demon
As it said in July, the bank reiterated that inflation will return to the 2 percent target by the end of 2024. This factors in additional rate hikes over the course of the projection horizon.
“Models are very useful. But models have limitations. And they have particular limitations when you’re going through something that is unprecedented as a pandemic and you’re bouncing back and you’re still dealing with the fallout of the pandemic,” Macklem said in response to a question from The Epoch Times.
“There’s also a war in Europe. So these are not things that our models are well equipped to deal with.”
One of the biggest concerns for the Bank of Canada is ensuring that inflation expectations remain under control; however, they remain high in the near term. Inflation expectations can be a self-fulfilling prophecy—if people expect prices to keep rising, then it’s more likely they will.
Based on survey responses, the BoC reported that uncertainty about the future path of inflation is high, but longer-term inflation expectations remain consistent with the 2 percent target.
A sign that inflation is coming down is the three-month consumer price index (CPI) inflation rate, which is well below the annual reading. The BoC said the three-month rates of core inflation point to a slowdown, though still averaging around 4 percent, while the average of the bank’s three preferred measures of core inflation—which minimizes the impact of more volatile items in the CPI—is 5.3 percent.
“We are also looking for evidence that near-term inflation expectations are easing and that longer-term expectations are centred on our 2 percent target,” Macklem said, regarding when the BoC can think of stopping rate increases.
Dehejia graded the BoC’s decision “A minus” given the “tricky balancing act” it faces; however, he “would have welcomed some acknowledgement that perhaps their looser stance [low interest rates] persisted longer in retrospect.”
